%
CapRateCity
Free cap rate calculators for every US market
← All Rankings

25 Highest Property Tax Cities for Investors (2026)

Property taxes can make or break a rental deal. These cities have the highest effective rates in our database — investors here need especially strong rent-to-price ratios to overcome the tax drag on NOI.

1
Camden, NJ2.28% tax rate
$155K median$1,080/mo rent4.7% cap rate0.1% growth
2
Trenton, NJ2.25% tax rate
$215K median$1,280/mo rent3.6% cap rate-0.1% growth
3
Newark, NJ2.21% tax rate
$360K median$1,680/mo rent2.3% cap rate0.4% growth
4
Paterson, NJ2.18% tax rate
$345K median$1,620/mo rent2.3% cap rate0.2% growth
5
Elizabeth, NJ2.15% tax rate
$380K median$1,720/mo rent2.2% cap rate0.3% growth
6
Rockford, IL2.12% tax rate
$135K median$920/mo rent4.7% cap rate-0.2% growth
7
Clifton, NJ2.12% tax rate
$420K median$1,850/mo rent2.1% cap rate0.2% growth
8
Peoria, IL2.1% tax rate
$125K median$880/mo rent4.9% cap rate-0.3% growth
9
Chicago, IL2.08% tax rate
$310K median$1,620/mo rent3.0% cap rate0.1% growth
10
Jersey City, NJ2.08% tax rate
$520K median$2,350/mo rent2.3% cap rate0.8% growth
11
Springfield, IL2.08% tax rate
$135K median$920/mo rent4.8% cap rate0.1% growth
12
Joliet, IL2.06% tax rate
$250K median$1,380/mo rent3.4% cap rate0.4% growth
13
Aurora, IL2.05% tax rate
$275K median$1,420/mo rent3.0% cap rate0.3% growth
14
Champaign, IL2.04% tax rate
$175K median$1,050/mo rent4.0% cap rate0.5% growth
15
Bloomington, IL2.02% tax rate
$185K median$1,100/mo rent3.9% cap rate0.3% growth
16
Naperville, IL2% tax rate
$440K median$1,950/mo rent2.3% cap rate0.5% growth
17
Racine, WI1.92% tax rate
$165K median$1,020/mo rent4.2% cap rate0.1% growth
18
Milwaukee, WI1.91% tax rate
$195K median$1,150/mo rent3.9% cap rate0.4% growth
19
Green Bay, WI1.88% tax rate
$210K median$1,100/mo rent3.3% cap rate0.5% growth
20
Kenosha, WI1.88% tax rate
$225K median$1,200/mo rent3.4% cap rate0.4% growth
21
Manchester, NH1.86% tax rate
$380K median$1,680/mo rent2.4% cap rate0.5% growth
22
Madison, WI1.85% tax rate
$360K median$1,580/mo rent2.4% cap rate1.2% growth
23
Appleton, WI1.85% tax rate
$225K median$1,150/mo rent3.2% cap rate0.6% growth
24
Concord, NH1.84% tax rate
$340K median$1,520/mo rent2.5% cap rate0.3% growth
25
Plano, TX1.82% tax rate
$420K median$1,900/mo rent2.5% cap rate1.6% growth
The CapRateCity Report
Weekly market analysis: highest cap rate cities, emerging markets, and deal breakdowns. Free, no spam.